Virtopsy (virtual autopsy) in forensic dentistry: features and perspectives
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.32782/2786-7684/2024-1-8Keywords:
forensic dentistry, virtopsy, virtual autopsy, maxillo-facial region, cone beam computed tomographyAbstract
Introduction. Virtopsy or virtual autopsy is a scientific and practical approach, which is based on the use of digital imaging methods for the purpose of identifying and objectifying changes within the structure of the human body, or its separate parts, without invasive interventions, or with the minimization of such interventions to a critically minimal necessary extent. Objective of the research. To analyze the possibilities of the virtopsy method as a modern approach to the objectification of dental status changes based on the digital analysis of data within the practice of forensic dentistry. Materials and methods. Accumulation of data regarding previous results of the virtopsy method application within the forensic dental practice was carried out on the basis of a search for targeted publications in the Google Scholar system (https:// scholar.google.com/) using the following keywords «virtopsy», «forensic», «dentistry», «forensic odontology» and realizing advanced search functions without applying any filters regarding the depth of the search and the design of the studies that were selected for further content analysis. Results and discussions. The implementation of virtopsy in modern forensic dental practice involves the use of a number of methods as sources to obtain digital data about a person: digital medical/dental documentation (data from the patient's digital register, data from the patient's digital dental card, data from the digital periodontal chart), digital photography (data from the digital registration protocol of changes within dental status during treatment and obtained during forensic dental examinations), digital intraoral scans or digital scans of stone casts, digital bite registers, digital scans of bite marks, digital dental radiographs, digital tomograms (cone-beam computed tomography results and magnetic resonance imaging results), data of three-dimensional scanning/photographing of surfaces provided by the photogrammetry method, digital external 3D scans of the face. Despite the advantages of using the virtopsy method in dental practice, there are certain disadvantages that limit its wide implementation, which include following: high cost of the technology, lack of unified standards for working with the technology, limitation of visualization to the minimum technological characteristics of the devices used, impossibility of assessing the characteristics of smell and color, scanning quality dependence on the characteristics of the investigated surfaces, the risk of losing individual data when combining the results of different imaging methods, not all pathological conditions can be verified or differentiated using the virtopsy method, the lack of the necessary amount of evidences and such of high quality regarding the effectiveness of the technology, the problem of differentiating artifacts related to the state of the body and its changes before and after death. Conclusions. The advantages of using the virtopsy method in forensic dental practice are the quick manner of providing such procedure, possibility of working with data within a digital environment, minimization of the need for invasive interventions and the risks associated with them, the perspective of processing and analysis of data/evidences within three-dimensional space, optimization of conditions for data storage, safe transfer and access to such data with the possibility of involvement several specialists at once, reduction of the evidence subjective interpretation effect, facilitating the possibility of checking evidences through remote access.
References
A practical guide to virtual autopsy: why, when and how / L. Filograna, L. Pugliese, M. Muto et al. Seminars in Ultrasound, CT and MRI. 2019. Vol. 40(1). P. 56–66.
Ahuja P., Ansari N. Virtopsy: A New Era in Forensic Medico-Legal Autopsies. Autopsy-What Do We Learn from Corpses? 2022. IntechOpen. Vol. Chapter. P. 1–11.
Azizah W. N., Oscandar F., Damayanti M. A. Systematic review: oral and maxillofacial radiology as fundamental methods of virtual autopsy. Forensic Sciences Research. 2023. Vol. 8(3). P. 185–197.
Bae E. J., Woo E. J. Quantitative and qualitative evaluation on the accuracy of three intraoral scanners for human identification in forensic odontology. Anatomy & Cell Biology. 2022. Vol. 55(1). P. 72.
Bolliger S. A., Thali M. J. Imaging and virtual autopsy: looking back and forward. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 2015. Vol. 370(1674). P. 20140253.
Digital forensic osteology–possibilities in cooperation with the Virtopsy® project / M. A. Verhoff, F. Ramsthaler, J. Krähahn et al. Forensic science international. 2008. Vol. 174(2-3). P. 152–156.
Digitization in forensic odontology: A paradigm shift in forensic investigations / R. Nagi, K. Aravinda, N. Rakesh et al. Journal of forensic dental sciences. 2019. Vol. 11(1). P. 5.
Feasibility and validation of virtual autopsy for dental identification using the Interpol dental codes / A. Franco, P. Thevissen, W. Coudyzer et al. Journal of forensic and legal medicine. 2013. Vol. 20(4). P. 248–254.
Forensic Imaging in Denmark, 20-year-experience: status and future directions: A positional statement from the Danish Forensic Imaging Group, of the Danish Association of Forensic Medicine / C. Villa, S. T. Larsen, K. Hansen et al. Forensic Imaging. 2024. Vol. 37(8). P. 200583.
Forensic odontology with digital technologies: A systematic review / S. Matsuda, H. Yoshida, K. Ebata et al. Journal of forensic and legal medicine. 2022. Vol. 74. P. 102004.
Goncharuk-Khomyn M. Digital Approaches in Forensic Dentistry Practice: Clustering or Fractal Differentiation?. Journal of Dentistry. 2022. Vol. 121. P. 103970.
Habiburrahman M., Wardoyo M. P., Yudhistira A. Virtopsy as a breakthrough in non-invasive autopsy: its principles and potential of application in developing countries during the COVID-19 pandemic. Journal of Health and Translational Medicine (JUMMEC). 2023. Vol. 26(2). P. 28–50.
Image guided virtual autopsy: An adjunct with radiographic and computed tomography modalities-An important tool in forensic identification / S. Rai, D. Misra, K. Tyagi et al. Journal of Indian Academy of Oral Medicine and Radiology. 2017. Vol. 29(4). P. 368–370.
Intraoral scanners in personal identification of corpses: Usefulness and reliability of 3D technologies in modern forensic dentistry / A. Putrino, V. Bruti, E. Marinelli et al. The Open Dentistry Journal. 2020. Vol. 14(1). P. 255–266.
Kadaiah B., Gowda C. Oral autopsy: A simple, faster procedure for total visualization of oral cavity. Journal of Forensic Dental Sciences. 2016. Vol. 8(2). P. 103–107.
Liu C., Ali N. L. Co-citation and bibliographic coupling based on connected papers: review of public opinion research in a broad sense in the west. Asian Social Science. 2022. Vol. 18(7). P. 29.
Maley S., Higgins D. Validity of postmortem computed tomography for use in forensic odontology identification casework. Forensic Science, Medicine and Pathology. 2023. Vol. 20(1). P. 43–50.
Nuzzolese E. Virdentopsy: Virtual dental autopsy and remote forensic odontology evaluation. Dentistry Journal. 2021. Vol. 9(9). P. 102.
Odontological identification dental charts based upon postmortem computed tomography compared to dental charts based upon postmortem clinical examinations / N. D. Jensen, P. C. Ulloa, S. Arge et al. Forensic Science, Medicine and Pathology. 2020. Vol. 16(2). P. 272–280.
Petersen M. V., Thomsen A. H., Hansen, K. FATAL: A Forensic AuTopsy Annotation tooL for digital recording of autopsy findings. medRxiv. 2024. P. 1–23.
Phulari R. G., Solanki B., Vasavada D. Virtopsy: a new developing science in forensic odontology. Stomatology Edu Journal. 2022. Vol. 9. P. 115–119.
Role of Various Stakeholders in Application of Artificial Intelligence to Forensic Odontology-A Potential Perspective / J. Pathak, N. Swain, D. Pathak et al. Annals of Dental Specialty. 2021. Vol. 9(1-2021). P. 47–52.
Sathyan P. VIRTOPSY: future of autopsy?. J Ind Dent Assoc Kochi. 2022. Vol. 4(2). P. 10–9.
Semiautomated robotic, CT-guided needle placement for postmortem CSF sampling–a Novel application of the Virtobot / S. Franckenberg, T. Sieberth, T. Frauenfelder et al. All Life. 2021. Vol. 14(1). P. 75–79.
Surabhi T. M., Bhateja S., Arora G. Virtopsy: an aid in forensic investigation. IP International Journal of Forensic Medicine and Toxicological Sciences. 2019. Vol. 4(4). P. 95–98.
Villa C., Lynnerup N., Jacobsen C. A virtual, 3D multimodal approach to victim and crime scene reconstruction. Diagnostics. 2023. Vol. 13(17). P. 2764.
Villa C., Flies M. J., Jacobsen C. Forensic 3D documentation of bodies: Simple and fast procedure for combining CT scanning with external photogrammetry data. Journal of Forensic Radiology and Imaging. 2017. Vol. 10. P. 47–51.
Virtobot–a multi‐functional robotic system for 3D surface scanning and automatic post mortem biopsy / L. C. Ebert, W. Ptacek, S. Naether et al. The international journal of medical robotics and computer assisted surgery. 2010. Vol. 6(1). P. 18–27.
Virtopsy approach: structured reporting versus free reporting for PMCT findings / W. Schweitzer, C. Bartsch, T. D. Ruder et al. Journal of Forensic Radiology and Imaging. 2014. Vol. 2(1). P. 28–33.
VIRTOPSY: minimally invasive, imaging-guided virtual autopsy / R. Dirnhofer, C. Jackowski, P. Vock et al. Radiographics. 2006. Vol. 26(5). P. 1305–1333.
Virtopsy® / W. Schweitzer, M. Thali, R. Breitbeck et al. Health Manag. 2014. Vol. 14(2). P. 37.
Virtopsy–radiology in forensic medicine / S. Grabherr, B. A. Stephan, U. Buck et al. Imaging Decisions MRI. 2007. Vol. 11(1). P. 2–9.
Virtual autopsy as a screening test before traditional autopsy: the verona experience on 25 cases / V. Cirielli, L. Cima, F. Bortolotti et al. Journal of pathology informatics. 2018. Vol. 9(1). P. 28.
Virtual autopsy using imaging: bridging radiologic and forensic sciences. A review of the Virtopsy and similar projects / S. A. Bolliger, M. J. Thali, S. Ross et al. European radiology. 2008. Vol. 18. P. 273–282.
Visual research discovery using connected papers: A use case of blockchain in libraries / A. Kaur, R. Sharma, P. Mishra et al. The Serials Librarian. 2022. Vol. 83(2). P. 186–196.
Yadav J., Yadav M. Virtual Autopsy–Way forward in Forensic Medicine. Journal of Indian Academy of Forensic Medicine. 2021. Vol. 43(4). P. 374–378.
Zangari F. Personal identification and ethical values. The Journal of Forensic Science Education. 2022. Vol. 4(2). P. 1–4.